|
(Preliminary Examination: Current Affairs)
(Mains Examination, General Studies Paper 4: Ethics in Private and Public Relations, Moral and Political Interest; Ethical Issues in International Relations and Funding; Code of Ethics, Code of Conduct)
|
Context
The controversy surrounding the absence of handshakes during the T20 match between India and Pakistan during the Asia Cup 2025 was in the news. The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) filed a complaint with the ICC regarding the players' handshakes before and after the match, while the Indian team rejected it. This issue raises a conflict over the balance between the spirit of cricket and nationalism.
About the Recent Controversy
- Match: During the India vs. Pakistan match at the Dubai International Cricket Stadium in the Asia Cup 2025.
- Incident: The PCB alleges that match referee Andy Pycroft asked the two captains not to shake hands during the toss.
- India's Response: Indian team sources said they were not informed of any such action.
PCB's Allegations
- PCB Chairman Mohsin Naqvi filed a complaint with the ICC.
- Allegation: The match referee violated the ICC Code of Conduct and the MCC's Laws of Cricket.
- PCB Demands: The referee be immediately removed from the Asia Cup.
- The PCB cited Article 2.1.1, which covers any minor infraction against the spirit of the game.
Spirit of Cricket
- The Spirit of Cricket refers to:
- Respect on and off the field
- Respect for opposing players and umpires
- Maintaining the traditional values of the game
Provisions related to the ICC Code of Conduct
Article 2.1.1 – Violations of the Spirit of Cricket
- This article covers all behavior that is against the Spirit of Cricket but does not fall under any specific offense.
- Examples: Disrespecting the umpire or opposing player, violating the traditions of the game, and using inappropriate behavior or language.
Article 2.2: Respect for Opponents, Umpires, and the Game
- Players and captains are required to maintain respectful behavior toward opponents, umpires, and the game.
- Its purpose is to maintain the values and traditional respect of the game.
Article 2.3: Captains' Responsibilities
- Captains have a duty to guide their team to behave in accordance with the spirit of the game.
- In any dispute or tense situation during a match, the captain must make calm and respectful decisions.
Article 2.4: Adherence to MCC Laws
- The ICC Code of Conduct mandates adherence to the Laws of Cricket set by the Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC).
- The Preamble to the Laws of Cricket defines the Spirit of Cricket, which includes:
- Adhering to the Laws of the Game
- Respecting the Umpire's Decisions
- Respecting the Traditions and Ethics of the Game
Provisions for Sportsmanship
- Handshakes are an age-old tradition, only discontinued during the pandemic.
- ICC and MCC rules encourage players to behave respectfully and in accordance with the spirit of the game.
- The spirit of sportsmanship aims to promote friendship and respect, not just competition.
Recent Contradictions with Nationalism
- Indian captain Suryakumar Yadav decided not to shake hands to honor the victims and soldiers of the Pahalgam terrorist attack.
- This move was contrary to traditional sportsmanship but was in line with national interests and nationalist sentiments.
- Pakistan felt that the Indian team violated the spirit of sportsmanship, while India held a different view.
India's View
- For India, national interests, sentiments, and sensitivities come first.
- According to Indian captain Suryakumar Yadav, "some things are above sportsmanship."
- The Indian team's view is that competition should continue in sports, but it is important to maintain respect for the victims of terrorism and the soldiers.
Conclusion
- This controversy highlights the balance between the spirit of sportsmanship and nationalism.
- The challenge for the ICC and the players is to maintain the appropriate balance between respect, sportsmanship, and national sentiments.
- Clear protocols and communication are needed for such matters in the future to maintain both the enjoyment and respect of the game.
|
About the Marylebone Cricket Club
- In cricket, the MCC is the Marylebone Cricket Club, a private club founded in 1787, and the custodian of the Laws of Cricket.
- Although it is no longer the sport's global governing body, it holds and maintains the copyright to the Laws of Cricket.
The MCC's Role
- Guardian of the Laws: The MCC is the body that protects and maintains the Laws of Cricket. The Laws of the Game are a code that outlines the rules of cricket worldwide to ensure fairness.
- Drafting the Laws: The MCC holds the copyright to the Laws of Cricket and is responsible for changing and interpreting them, working in conjunction with the International Cricket Council (ICC).
MCC and ICC
- Division of Responsibilities: The MCC In 1993, the MCC transferred many of the game's administrative and playing functions to the International Cricket Council (ICC).
- Regional roles: Although the MCC maintains the rules, the ICC is the global governing body for international cricket and is responsible for enforcing the rules and developing playing conditions.
|
Contact Us 
New Batch : 9555124124/ 7428085757 
Tech Support : 9555124124/ 7428085757
